‘Diabolical move’: Miranda Priestly’s red shoes get Instagram fashion no-no | Women’s shoes

Posting the primary trailer for The Satan Wears Prada 2 on Instagram on her birthday this week, the movie’s star Anne Hathaway captioned the video with “it’s everyone’s birthday”, prompting copious feedback that includes emojis of flames, hearts and – in fact – the purple shoe now related to the movie’s poster.However with the trailer circulating on social media, it’s the footwear which have develop into the main focus of vogue debate – and never in a great way.The trailer begins with the ft of the movie’s fearsome vogue editor, Miranda Priestly, sporting red-studded Rockstud stilettos made by Valentino in 2010, a shoe that grew to become fashionable with vogue editors of the last decade.It’s this that has precipitated offence – the concept that somebody so plugged into vogue can be sporting what is taken into account passe. On the Who What Put on Instagram account, in feedback beneath Hathaway’s submit, followers made their emotions identified. “Giving rockstuds that a lot airtime was a … alternative,” wrote one, whereas one other merely stated “no to footwear”.On TikTok, the creator NewsWithLils wrote: “I’m no vogue skilled however even I do know Miranda Priestly sporting Valentino rockstud footwear in 2025 is a diabolical transfer and never in a great way.”The response is in keeping with a wider pattern for on-line debate after the discharge of trailers or on-set pictures from movies and TV which have a vogue angle.skip previous e-newsletter promotionSign as much as Trend StatementStyle, with substance: what’s actually trending this week, a roundup of one of the best vogue journalism and your wardrobe dilemmas solvedPrivacy Discover: Newsletters might comprise details about charities, on-line adverts, and content material funded by exterior events. Should you shouldn’t have an account, we are going to create a visitor account for you on theguardian.com to ship you this text. You may full full registration at any time. For extra details about how we use your information see our Privateness Coverage. We use Google reCaptcha to guard our web site and the Google Privateness Coverage and Phrases of Service apply.after e-newsletter promotionThe red-studded Rockstud stilettos designed by Valentino in 2010. {Photograph}: twentieth Century Fox/AllstarIn June, pictures from the forthcoming biopic collection of Carolyn Bessette Kennedy have been launched, with the actor Sarah Pidgeon as Kennedy. They have been rapidly trashed by followers, with one describing the photographs as “vogue homicide”, with all the pieces from the shade of blond of Pidgeon’s hair to the “fallacious” purse changing into a supply of concern.Sturdy reactions round costumes display the love of vogue in movie and TV, which is one thing these making the exhibits are little doubt aware of – a lot so a preview of “wrongness” within the costumes may very well be deliberate and designed to get the web speaking and create extra buzz earlier than launch.With the Rockstud, there’s additionally the chance that the tide may flip and the shoe be considered as a intelligent alternative – as a result of one thing that feels so behind the instances is, in reality, ripe for a revival.“After I began at Vogue in 2011, I keep in mind Rockstuds being a well-recognized sight,” says Julia Hobbs, a senior contributing vogue options editor at Vogue. “In my thoughts, there’s one thing deeply nostalgic about them.”She suggests there may be extra to return with the movie. “If I have been to play satan’s advocate, I’d say I’m at all times right here for a classic shoe revival – if we are able to name the 2010s classic, which is a debate for an additional day,” she says. “And if anybody can kickstart a shoe pattern, it’s Miranda Priestly.”