Close Menu
OnlyPlanz –

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Get two months of Essential or Premium for only $2

    July 5, 2025

    ‘I questioned my decision of becoming a single parent’: Karan Johar on facing the worst troll in his life; ways to navigate criticism | Feelings News

    July 5, 2025

    Dealmakers hit pause on M&A as caution rules the boardroom

    July 5, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Get two months of Essential or Premium for only $2
    • ‘I questioned my decision of becoming a single parent’: Karan Johar on facing the worst troll in his life; ways to navigate criticism | Feelings News
    • Dealmakers hit pause on M&A as caution rules the boardroom
    • I was sexually assaulted by a celebrity after starring in a cult film at 19. My quest for justice changed the course of my life | Rape and sexual assault
    • Photos Show Deadly Texas Floods and Rescue Efforts
    • This Incredible Lens Let Me Take Amazing Star Photos
    • Oasis setlist for comeback tour with Wonderwall and Don’t Look Back in Anger
    • ‘Food demand in Cumbria is unprecedented’
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    OnlyPlanz –OnlyPlanz –
    • Home
    • Marketing
    • Branding
    • Modeling
    • Video Creation
    • Editing Tips
    • Content
    • Engagement
    • More
      • Tools
      • Earnings
      • Legal
      • Monetization
    OnlyPlanz –
    Home»Legal»Reluctant prosecutor can’t ‘manufacture mootness’ or ruin standing for inmate seeking DNA test, SCOTUS says
    Legal

    Reluctant prosecutor can’t ‘manufacture mootness’ or ruin standing for inmate seeking DNA test, SCOTUS says

    onlyplanz_80y6mtBy onlyplanz_80y6mtJune 27, 2025No Comments5 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit Telegram Email
    AP Texas inmate Ruben Gutierrez
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    House
    Internet First
    Reluctant prosecutor cannot ‘manufacture mootness’…

    U.S. Supreme Court docket

    Reluctant prosecutor cannot ‘manufacture mootness’ or wreck standing for inmate looking for DNA take a look at, SCOTUS says

    By Debra Cassens Weiss
    June 26, 2025, 11:42 am CDT

    Texas loss of life row inmate Ruben Gutierrez. (Picture supplied by the Texas Division of Felony Justice through the Related Press)

    A Texas loss of life row inmate who desires DNA testing to ascertain that he wasn’t at a homicide scene, though he helped plan a theft there, has standing to problem the state legislation governing testing procedures, the U.S. Supreme Court docket dominated Thursday.

    The Supreme Court docket dominated 6-3 for Texas inmate Ruben Gutierrez, who claims that he might problem the legislation, though prosecutors may not grant a DNA take a look at if he wins. He has standing, it doesn’t matter what the prosecutor might do, the bulk stated in an opinion by Justice Sonia Sotomayor.

    Her opinion was joined in full by the opposite liberal justices on the excessive court docket and by Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh. Justice Amy Coney Barrett joined all however one part of Sotomayor’s resolution.

    A DNA take a look at would possibly have an effect on Gutierrez’s sentence however not his conviction. Texas legislation permits testing solely in instances that might result in an overturned conviction. Gutierrez claimed that the legislation violates his rights underneath the due course of clause.

    Texas state legislation offers {that a} defendant might be discovered responsible of capital homicide, even after they had been merely a celebration to the crime leading to loss of life. However a defendant can’t be sentenced to loss of life except they triggered the loss of life, meant to kill or anticipated that an individual can be killed.

    Gutierrez claims that he thought that his two accomplices would rob an empty cell residence within the 1998 incident and by no means anticipated that somebody can be killed. He twice advised police that he was by no means contained in the cell residence however later gave police a press release that stated he was contained in the cell residence whereas an confederate fatally stabbed Escolastica Harrison with a screwdriver. He now claims that the confession was coerced.

    Gutierrez has sought DNA testing since 2010 to ascertain that solely his accomplices had been contained in the cell residence, and he’s ineligible for the loss of life penalty.

    The fifth U.S. Circuit Court docket of Appeals at New Orleans had held that Gutierrez’s claimed damage couldn’t be redressed by a win in his problem to the statute as a result of the prosecutor can be unlikely to permit the DNA take a look at in any occasion. A number of unbiased grounds help the prosecutor’s refusal to grant a DNA textual content, and the Texas legislation was only one motive, the federal appeals court docket stated.

    Sotomayor stated the fifth Circuit erred by “remodeling the redressability inquiry right into a guess as as to if a good court docket resolution will in actual fact finally trigger the prosecutor to show over the proof.”

    Sotomayor stated the fifth Circuit wrongly distinguished Reed v. Goertz, a 2023 Supreme Court docket resolution permitting a lawsuit by an inmate who sought a DNA take a look at in a federal civil rights swimsuit. The declaratory judgment requested by the inmate in that prior case was “no extra more likely to yield a change within the district legal professional’s conduct than the one Gutierrez sought right here,” Sotomayor wrote.

    The truth that the prosecutor in Gutierrez’s case refused to permit the DNA take a look at after Gutierrez received within the federal district court docket doesn’t make the inmate’s enchantment moot, Sotomayor stated.

    “A procedural due course of declare, just like the one Gutierrez presses, isn’t mooted by the defendant’s mid-appeal promise that, regardless of the results of a lawsuit, the last word consequence won’t change,” Sotomayor wrote. “Holding in any other case would permit all method of defendants to fabricate mootness.”

    In a partial concurrence and a concurrence within the judgment, Barrett stated Sotomayor’s opinion “muddies the waters of standing doctrine” by “borrowing from our somewhat-relaxed redressability inquiry in administrative-law procedural-injury instances.”

    Justice Samuel Alito dissented in an opinion joined by Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Neil Gorsuch.

    Alito stated the bulk “blatantly alters” the Reed take a look at for standing.

    “It then has the audacity to criticize the fifth Circuit for making use of the actual Reed take a look at,” Alito wrote.

    Shawn Nolan, a lawyer for Gutierrez, launched this assertion: “Right now, Ruben Gutierrez is one step nearer to proving that he was wrongfully sentenced to loss of life. The court docket’s resolution makes clear that Ruben has a authorized proper to problem the Texas post-conviction DNA statute, which limits his entry to DNA testing to indicate he mustn’t have been sentenced to loss of life. We belief the Cameron County district legal professional will heed the Supreme Court docket’s resolution and supply us, in the end, with entry to the in depth forensic proof in Ruben’s case.”

    The case is Gutierrez v. Saenz.

    Hat tip SCOTUSblog, which had early protection of the choice.

    See additionally:

    Anticipated noncompliance with court docket orders shouldn’t defeat standing, Kavanaugh says in DNA-test arguments

    Write a letter to the editor, share a narrative tip or replace, or report an error.

    DNA inmate manufacture mootness prosecutor Reluctant ruin SCOTUS seeking standing test
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleMeta Looks to Acquire More Talent for its Expanding AI Push
    Next Article How to Score a Neo-Noir, Paranoid Thriller Like ‘Gazer’
    onlyplanz_80y6mt
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Legal

    I was sexually assaulted by a celebrity after starring in a cult film at 19. My quest for justice changed the course of my life | Rape and sexual assault

    July 5, 2025
    Legal

    Crypto Scam Impersonates Trump-Vance Inaugural Committee

    July 5, 2025
    Legal

    A Look At How The Law Fails Patients

    July 5, 2025
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    5 Steps for Leading a Team You’ve Inherited

    June 18, 20255 Views

    A Pro-Russia Disinformation Campaign Is Using Free AI Tools to Fuel a ‘Content Explosion’

    July 1, 20253 Views

    Meera Sodha’s vegan recipe for Thai-style tossed walnut and tempeh noodles | Noodles

    June 28, 20252 Views
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews
    Tools

    Get two months of Essential or Premium for only $2

    onlyplanz_80y6mtJuly 5, 2025
    Modeling

    ‘I questioned my decision of becoming a single parent’: Karan Johar on facing the worst troll in his life; ways to navigate criticism | Feelings News

    onlyplanz_80y6mtJuly 5, 2025
    Earnings

    Dealmakers hit pause on M&A as caution rules the boardroom

    onlyplanz_80y6mtJuly 5, 2025

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest tech news from FooBar about tech, design and biz.

    Most Popular

    SLR reform is happening. Does it matter?

    June 18, 20250 Views

    Panthers in awe of Brad Marchand’s ‘will to win’ in Cup run

    June 18, 20250 Views

    CaliBBQ Saw 18% Sales Lift Using AI Agents for Father’s Day

    June 18, 20250 Views
    Our Picks

    Get two months of Essential or Premium for only $2

    July 5, 2025

    ‘I questioned my decision of becoming a single parent’: Karan Johar on facing the worst troll in his life; ways to navigate criticism | Feelings News

    July 5, 2025

    Dealmakers hit pause on M&A as caution rules the boardroom

    July 5, 2025
    Recent Posts
    • Get two months of Essential or Premium for only $2
    • ‘I questioned my decision of becoming a single parent’: Karan Johar on facing the worst troll in his life; ways to navigate criticism | Feelings News
    • Dealmakers hit pause on M&A as caution rules the boardroom
    • I was sexually assaulted by a celebrity after starring in a cult film at 19. My quest for justice changed the course of my life | Rape and sexual assault
    • Photos Show Deadly Texas Floods and Rescue Efforts
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • About Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    © 2025 ThemeSphere. Designed by Pro.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.