Sydney Sweeney’s newest marketing campaign for American Eagle seems to be, on the floor, like a textbook win. The imagery is wealthy with sun-faded nostalgia, classic muscle automobiles, basic denim, and a heat palette. It’s Americana with a high-gloss end, tailored for TikTok’s aesthetic sensibilities. On paper, it follows all the foundations of making probably the greatest adverts of all time. However the web had different plans.As a substitute of a common thumbs-up, the Sydney Sweeney American Eagle marketing campaign drew backlash from youthful audiences who noticed the visuals not as innocent nostalgia however as a glossed-over tackle a really loaded cultural legacy. Phrases like “performative,” “exclusionary,” and “tone-deaf” surfaced throughout X (Twitter), Reddit, and Instagram. The blowback raises a a lot bigger query: has Gen Z fallen out of affection with Americana, or are they merely demanding it develop up?For a middle-Gen-Xer, I used to be left scratching my head a bit; I grew up on Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen and, for my sins, the double-denim hair-rock of Bon Jovi; we had Again to the Future, The Breakfast Membership, and Stand By Me. We celebrated the American dream however critiqued it, after which Nirvana blew all of it up with Smells Like Teen Spirit and In Bloom, and we sang even louder from the identical songbook.
Chances are you’ll like
(Picture credit score: American Eagle)So I used to be left scratching my head over the American Eagle whoo-ha. I would not say American Eagle got down to wade into tradition battle territory. This can be a model constructed on relaxed Americana; youthful, laid-back authenticity, freedom, and self-expression, not battle traces. But in 2025, nothing is impartial, particularly not the American flag, classic muscle automobiles and pick-up vehicles, or a slice of Most important Road attraction. For Gen Z, these pictures don’t simply sign freedom and youth; they’ve develop into flashpoints in an ongoing dialog about identification, energy, and exclusion.This sensitivity isn’t new, particularly for Sydney Sweeney. In 2022, a birthday celebration for a member of the family that includes crimson MAGA-style hats and Western-themed décor led to an internet uproar. Although Sweeney wasn’t straight accountable, and he or she’s by no means revealed her politics, the optics triggered a collective side-eye from Gen Z, a technology raised on media literacy, Google sleuthing, and a pointy consciousness of subtext.(Picture credit score: American Eagle)So, why does this matter now?Gen Z is rising up in an America far completely different from the one romanticised in Levi’s advertisements of the ’90s or Bruce Springsteen’s Born in the usA. A 2021 Pew Analysis research discovered that solely 16% of Gen Z adults reported being “extraordinarily proud” to be American, in comparison with 42% of Child Boomers. For them, the flag is simply as more likely to invoke pictures of division, of the Capitol riots, immigration bans, ebook censorship, as it’s yard barbecues.And but, Gen Z isn’t anti-nostalgia; fairly the other. TikTok, design, and artwork tendencies lean closely on retro aesthetics: suppose VHS filters, disposable cameras, and low-fi nation songs repackaged for sad-girl playlists. The aesthetic of Americana is alive and thriving, simply not uncritically. In keeping with YPulse’s 2024 Model Tracker, 72% of Gen Z customers say it’s vital for manufacturers to “stand for one thing,” and 66% imagine manufacturers ought to “acknowledge social points.” If you happen to’re going to borrow the visible language of American heritage, you’d higher convey the context too.Every day design information, evaluations, how-tos and extra, as picked by the editors.Some manufacturers do get it proper. Levi’s has developed right into a progressive heritage label, spotlighting sustainability, racial fairness, and LGBTQ+ tales by means of inclusive campaigns. Beyoncé’s Cowboy Carter is one other masterclass in reimagining Americana. She didn’t reject it, she remixed it. Reclaiming nation music by means of a Black feminist lens. And Gen Z artists can champion Americana however on their phrases, resembling Lana Del Rey and, clearly, Taylor Swift, who has develop into the golden ticket for rebranding nation music and imagery into one thing everybody can love.That is the place American Eagle’s marketing campaign stumbles. The visuals are polished, however context is absent. A stunning shot of Sydney leaning on a rusty Camaro doesn’t really feel like a love letter to America; it seems like a sepia-toned fantasy that ignores who constructed these roads, who bought left behind, and who was by no means pictured within the first place.For a technology fluent in Photoshop, deep fakes, and protest indicators, introduced up underneath the spectre of 9/11, the rise of social media, local weather nervousness, recession, and Covid, a flag isn’t only a flag, a slogan lands in a different way, and denims, effectively… blue double-denim feels loaded.(Picture credit score: American Eagle)The way forward for AmericanaBut this isn’t all unhealthy information. Gen Z isn’t cancelling Americana, they’re enhancing it. They need tales that embrace them and others, not simply evoke base nostalgia however scratch under the floor of what is being celebrated. Which means the liberty to romanticise dusty diners and previous vehicles, but additionally the accountability to highlight the individuals who’ve been neglected of these tales for many years.If American Eagle needs to maintain its crown because the denim of youth tradition, it doesn’t must ditch the street journey fantasy, however perhaps this time, it picks up a number of extra passengers alongside the way in which. As a result of Gen Z doesn’t need to burn the flag, they simply need it to imply one thing extra significant than slavish adoration for one view of the previous.
